top of page

Harnessing the Herd: Turning Startup Skepticism into a Marketing Advantage

When it comes to entrepreneurship, understanding human behavior isn't just about navigating personal relationships—it's also about leveraging psychological principles to drive your business to its success. The phenomenon of "the bandwagon effect"—which I still think should be called the sheep effect—can be more than just a challenge for startups; it can also be a powerful marketing tool. Here's how you can switch it up and flip this behavior to your advantage.

Create Social Proof

Just as family and friends wait to see if someone else is interested in a new thing, potential customers often do the same before making a purchase. Encourage early adopters and satisfied customers to leave reviews, testimonials, and social media endorsements. This helps big time and these positive signals can influence others to follow suit, building momentum for your brand.

Looking at social media on an iPhone

Leverage Influencers

Influencer marketing capitalizes on the herd mentality by associating your brand with people who have a large and loyal following. When influencers endorse your product or service, their followers are more likely to follow suit, trusting the judgment of someone they admire. Choose influencers whose values align with your brand and whose followers represent your target audience. 

social media influencer

bottle of wine
Highlight Popularity

People are drawn to what's popular and trendy. Use this to your advantage by showcasing the growing popularity of your product or service. Display customer counts, social media followers, or sales figures prominently on your website and marketing materials. The perception of popularity can attract even more customers, creating a self-perpetuating cycle of growth.

Create a Sense of Urgency 

Scarcity and urgency are powerful motivators. Tap into the fear of missing out by creating limited-time offers, exclusive deals, or product launches with a countdown timer. When people see others rushing to take advantage of an opportunity, they're more likely to join the fray rather than risk being left behind.

Encourage User-Generated Content

Invite your customers to become part of your brand story by sharing their experiences and creations. User-generated content not only serves as social proof but also fosters a sense of community around your brand. Encourage customers to share photos, videos, and testimonials showcasing how they use your product or service in their lives.

Build Trust Through Transparency

In a world where skepticism runs high, transparency is key to building trust. Be open and honest about your business practices, values, and the people behind the brand. Share behind-the-scenes glimpses, customer success stories, and any challenges you've overcome. I can’t stress enough how much authenticity breeds loyalty, and loyal customers become your strongest advocates.

A man weraing a salmon colored graphic tee from The BACo Store

While the herd mentality can present challenges for startups seeking support from friends and family, it also presents a unique opportunity for savvy marketers. By understanding and harnessing the power of social proof, influencers, popularity, urgency, user-generated content, and transparency, you can turn sheep behavior into a valuable marketing tool. Embrace the herd but lead the flock and watch your business thrive.


If you’ve taken my advice let me know how it goes. I’m all for business and brand development.


Things to do in Jersey City and Hoboken
Things to do in NYC
bottom of page